Even when a CT scan or MRI comes back normal, a brain injury may still be present. Dirk J. Derrick, Esq., joined by Pearl Carey, on the firm's professional staff, explains why traumatic brain injuries may not be identified during an initial emergency room evaluation and why neither a blow to the head nor a loss of consciousness is required. Dirk describes the changes families should watch for after a concussion, such as irritability, memory trouble, difficulty tolerating noisy places, and shifts in personality. He walks through the five factors his firm considers when evaluating and establishing a traumatic brain injury claim, particularly when conventional imaging is normal , the treatments that help survivors adapt, and what focus group participants weigh when valuing these life-changing claims.

While past results do not guarantee future results, you are guaranteed our best efforts. Dirk J. Derrick, 901 Main St., Conway, SC, 29526.

Dirk Derrick (00:00):

Welcome to The Legal Truth, the podcast created to provide you general legal information about South Carolina law, lawyers, and the legal process, and hopefully prevent you from being surprised by the unexpected. We will answer many of the questions I've been asked during the past 38 years about South Carolina personal injury claims and workers' compensation claims. We'll also discuss existing laws and proposed changes in the law and how they affect you. My name is Dirk Derrick. I'm the founder of Derrick Law Firm Injury Lawyers, and I'm your host.

Voiceover (00:32):

Please see required ethics disclaimers in show notes.

Pearl Carey (00:40):

Welcome back to The Legal Truth. Today we are here to discuss the truth about traumatic brain injuries. I'm Pearl Carey and I'm here with my co-host, Dirk Derrick. Thanks for being here, Dirk.

Dirk Derrick (00:49):

Glad to be here.

Pearl Carey (00:50):

And my first question for you is, what is a traumatic brain injury?

Dirk Derrick (00:54):

A traumatic brain injury is when an external force disrupts the normal activity of a brain. It can be caused by direct impact and it can be caused by acceleration and deceleration of the head, and it happens quite often in wrecks. Lately, we are learning more about them because of technology and the degree at which we are studying the brain and the consequences of these TBIs. You probably heard of CTE, whole football thing. You see football players now starting to play with the pads on top of the helmets. That's a new thing you see. Why is that football player's head so big where they're putting additional pads on top of the hard helmets? Because of the amount of CTEs they're discovering after people play football. So that's what a traumatic brain injury is. Whiplash, impact, direct impacts. For older people, a lot of times it's false, can cause them. A lot of TBIs in soccer, they don't have helmets on running around the field, but that's an injury to the brain that's caused by trauma is the big picture answer.

Pearl Carey (02:00):

So I know that you talked about football players maybe discovering later in life that they do have a traumatic brain injury. So how often do emergency rooms initially miss that their patient might actually have a traumatic brain injury?

Dirk Derrick (02:13):

It's missed a lot. When you go to an emergency room, what they're looking for is something that's going to kill you. If you're in the ER, if you have a brain injury or a head injury and you come to the ER, what they look at mostly is do you have a brain bleed? Do you have a fracture of the skull? Do you have a brain bleed? Do you have anything that is severe enough to be life-threatening? They often categorize these initial injuries as mild, moderate, or severe, but that classification does not describe what the end product may be down the road. It is how bad is it right now? And people go in, I hit my head, got a headache. They're looking, they may diagnose concussion, a lot of concussions in wrecks, but concussion is a brain injury. It's just it's classified as a mild brain injury in the ER most of the time, but that does not mean that it won't have lingering effects and devastating effects later on.

(03:07):

If the person has a fractured skull, they got a brain bleed, the brain is swelling, they're having to take off part of the skull because of the swelling, well, that's a terrible injury, but it's a very easy injury to prove. The harder cases to prove are the ones that don't have that, that have the injury to the brain, it's not showing up on any of the imaging at the ER, but the consequences are bad down the road.

Pearl Carey (03:30):

So now that we've discussed how TBIs might be difficult to initially diagnose in an emergency room setting, does someone have to have hit their head or have lost consciousness to actually have and be suffering with a TBI?

Dirk Derrick (03:42):

No, it can be caused by direct impact. It can also be caused by acceleration, deceleration. If you get swung around, understand that your brain is inside the skull and if you throw it against one side of the skull and it goes back against the other side of the skull violently, that can cause brain injury. It's what caused concussion. In football, when you ring your bell, but it does not have to be caused by direct impact. The loss of consciousness is not necessary. Usually when we're trying to prove TBIs, you have to prove there's a mechanism of injury that a TBI can occur from, and that's a direct impact. Slam your head on the side window, hit your head, the force of the impact would cause you to accelerate and decelerate. You also want to prove not only mechanism of injury, but the doctor's also looking for an acute alteration in brain function.

(04:33):

And that doesn't have to be loss of consciousness. It can be confusion. It can be disorientation. It can be, I had my bell rung. I was thrown off. I was foggy. I don't remember if I was unconscious or how long I was unconscious. It's funny how many times our clients are asked in the ER, "Did you lose consciousness?" Some will say yes. Some will say, "No, I don't think so. I was shook up. I don't think I've lost consciousness." Some say, "I have no idea." And the truth is asking the person who lost consciousness if they lost consciousness and how long they were unconscious, you think about it, that's kind of ridiculous question. These people aren't good people to give you the answers to that because if you had any kind of alteration to your mental status, you're shaken up, do you actually know if you lost consciousness?

(05:18):

From our standpoint, it is why we really want to talk to the witnesses who come to the scene or the first responders and try to determine the time that they were unconscious if they were. And when we're talking to our clients, we don't ask the question, hey, did you lose consciousness? What's the last thing you remembered and what's the next thing you remembered after the wreck? If the last thing they remembered is hearing the tires squealing behind them or the last thing they remember is just a huge impact, and then the next thing they remembered is somebody standing at the door talking to them, we can put the time together. We can figure out how much time that was. So it doesn't require total loss of consciousness. The doctors are looking for it and we're looking in proving a brain injury, some kind of altered mental status to go on top of the mechanism of injury. Mechanism of injury, altered mental status are the two foundations.

Pearl Carey (06:12):

Got it. And so when these doctors are looking for certain signs and symptoms of TBIs, what kinds of tests or imaging is most useful?

Dirk Derrick (06:20):

I would tell you that at the ER, they often run CAT scans and MRIs. And a CAT scan can be absolutely normal when you have a TBI. MRI can be absolutely normal when you have a TBI. Those are looking for bleeds. They're looking for fractures of the skull. Those do not rule out TBI because they're normal at the emergency department. Defense lawyers love to wave them up. They love to wave them at the jury, normal CT, normal MRI, and try to confuse people. The medical text and the journals, it's undeniable that those things can be negative and you still have a TBI. So if you go to the ER, you have an injury, your head's hurting, you had altered mental status, you got slammed or your head got swung around and they say your MRI and your CAT scan are normal, that's great. That probably means you don't have a fracture, you don't have a bleed. Does not mean that you don't have a TBI that will give you problems in the future.

Pearl Carey (07:15):

So when we're speaking about some symptoms that people who have TBIs undergo, what should families watch out for in terms of post-concussion syndrome?

Dirk Derrick (07:24):

That's a great question. I think family members, even more so than the injured person, can be the most important witnesses regarding someone having a TBI. What is the general thing that we see over and over? Diagnosed with a concussion, maybe even diagnosed with post-concussive syndrome that this concussion is lasting longer than normal. And then the family member comes and tells us they're not acting like themselves. They're more irritable. They can't be around loud music or children. Having trouble with remembering stuff. They're having balancing problems. Their personality seems to be different. I have a total list of things that we tell spouses and family members to look out for.

(08:06):

Difficulty concentrating, reading or multitasking, becoming an unusually irritable, impatient or emotional, needing more sleep or becoming exhausted easily, headaches, dizziness, nausea or sensitivity to light, difficulty tolerating noisy and crowded environment, balance problems, blurred vision or trouble tracking objects. Depression, anxiety, withdrawal or personality changes, difficulty handling finances, scheduling or work responsibilities, loss of interest in hobbies or family activities. We really want to know if these things exist for our clients because we want to be able to give them help and get them to the right places to get help if they're having these symptoms.

Pearl Carey (08:44):

Absolutely. So they can get the help that they need. And so can a mild traumatic brain injury cause problems or even last for years?

Dirk Derrick (08:51):

Oh yeah. There's some medical journals talking about it's a mild traumatic brain injuries if it happened to somebody else. If it happens to you, it's not mild because the consequences of it are anything other than mild. There's some medical journals talking about brain injuries are a disease process once they happen and they do damage inside the brain and it can grow as far as the resulting consequences of that. It can last forever. It can start changing your things that we just listed and they can remain with you for life.

Pearl Carey (09:24):

Yeah. So it can permanently alter this individual's life forever.

Dirk Derrick (09:28):

I got some stats I pulled for the podcast. This is a JMA neurology in 2019. They were doing some research on TBIs. Researchers studied 1,154 patients with mild traumatic brain injuries and compared them with 299 orthopedic trauma patients. Functional limitations one year after injury with mild TBIs, 53%. 53% of the mild TBI group reported functional limitations at one year compared with only 38% of people with orthopedic injuries. People have bones, injuries, that kind of stuff. After one year, 38% of them have functional problems. 53% of TBI patients have functional problems with a mild TBI diagnosis. These statistics do not mean that 53% of everyone with a concussion will become permanently disabled. People who have concussions, some of them heal up. They don't have limitations. And a lot of times when we have clients who've had concussions or post-concussive syndrome, we're looking at them and we don't know. Fortunately, some people heal up, they're fine. Sometimes it's just wait and see to see the people who heal and people who don't heal.

Pearl Carey (10:36):

Absolutely. And so how do you prove a traumatic brain injury in court when the CT and MRI are normal?

Dirk Derrick (10:41):

I think there's five things that we really look at in trying to prove problems caused by TBI. First, you want to know, what was the person like before this happened? Family, coworkers, supervisors, how did this person function? What was their personality? What could they handle? What was their capacity physically, mentally, socially, everything about the person. Who was this person? Secondly, you prove what happened, the mechanism of injury with the things we talked about, through witnesses, through evidence, through accident reconstructionists, through experts as far as the degree of impact somebody had on their brain during this incident.

(11:19):

Third, you look at, what changed? From that first person we knew, we had this incident, what changed in them? What's different about them? Fourth, what does objective clinical testing show? There's ways now that you can test someone. There's some DTIs, there's neuropsychological testing. There's other things that we can test and the test results by themselves doesn't prove functional problems because of TBI, but you look at it in the big picture, who they were before, what happened, what changed, and then you do these DTIs and neuropsychological tests, have experts test other aspects, other systems that may be affected by TBI, but you're trying to see what the objective testing shows on top of the other three things that you have come through and you have checked off.

(12:08):

The fifth thing is trying to determine whether or not there's other reasonable explanations to cause some of the test results, pain, poor sleep, medication effects, depression, anxiety, PTSD, and preexisting conditions can produce overlapping symptoms. So you're looking to see what preexisting conditions and problems would explain this thing if it's not caused by the TBI. Probably most persuasive cases connect a medically supported diagnosis to credible evidence of real world functional change. So if you have medical testing that shows it, if you have, of course, at the ER, you have medical testing and imaging that shows it immediately, that's a stronger case than the ones that they don't see. It's putting together a puzzle. Of course, it's a lot easier if someone has a rod in their spine or in their femur to show the jury a picture of it, say, "Look at that, there's the injury," in putting together a TBI case. But we're getting better. The technology's getting better. Experts understand it better now. So it's a lot easier to prove these TBIs now than it was 20 years ago.

Pearl Carey (13:15):

Absolutely. So in terms of these TBI survivors, what is their short-term and long-term outlook? How are these injuries treated over time?

Dirk Derrick (13:24):

Treatment depends on the severity at the time of the incident. Of course, if somebody has moderate or severe brain injury at the time of the incident, they're going to be kept in the hospital, maybe ICU to make sure any bleeding stops, any swelling is under control. If you have a TBI that's causing swelling in the brain and the blood in the skull and all that can be very, very dangerous. And so all of that is treated in the hospital. People who are diagnosed with mild concussions, they're usually told to go home and rest, really take it easy, don't push your brain, just kind of chill for 24, 48 hours. Later on, you really treat the symptoms. There's no way to go fix a brain injury and just, "Okay, bam, we're fixed, everything's gone." So you kind of treat the symptoms that it's causing. That can be treated by a number of different doctors.

(14:11):

I put a list of different doctors or different treatments some of our clients have had and that other people have in TBI cases. You get treatment for dizziness and balance problems. You get cervical physical therapy when neck injuries contribute to headaches and dizziness. You can get cognitive rehabilitation for attention and memory difficulties, occupational therapy for work and daily activities, speech language therapy for cognitive communication problems, behavioral health treatment for depression, anxiety, trauma symptoms, and emotional regulation. Sleep evaluation and treatment for people having trouble sleeping after TBIs, specialized headache management, coordinated rehabilitation and graded return to work planning. Basically, whatever the problem somebody's having, and they can be different from different people, TBI, injury, you treat the symptoms, and there's a lot of people to treat them. Even when you can't make them all disappear, rehabilitation can help people recover abilities and adapt to limitations and improve their quality of life. And that's what it's all about. You're trying to get them back to normal as much as possible when you can't just wave a wand and fix a brain injury.

Pearl Carey (15:23):

Absolutely. And so if somebody ends up in a car wreck or something of that nature and they suspect that they do have a TBI, what should they do from there?

Dirk Derrick (15:32):

First of all, if you go to emergency room with a head injury or headaches or concussion or loss of consciousness or disorientation after a wreck, whatever, you report what happened and do what the doctors tell you to do. If the doctors release you and diagnose a concussion or post-concussive syndrome later on, don't think that you're completely out of the woods just because your MRI or CT scan were normal. If symptoms linger or new symptoms come on, can't sleep, change of personalities, memory problems, functional problems that we listed a while ago, if you have any of those, seek medical treatment. And when you seek medical treatment, you need to let that doctor know of the mechanism of injury that happened. "I had a wreck a month ago. MRI and CT were normal, but I'm having these problems. I had a fall six months ago. I have not been normal since and it's gotten worse and worse," but you want to get a doctor involved with your treatment as early as possible.

Pearl Carey (16:25):

So Dirk, tell me a little bit about how South Carolina jurors view TBIs and how do they compensate victims of TBIs?

Dirk Derrick (16:33):

We've done quite a few of focus groups on TBIs and it comes down to the credibility of the plaintiff and the people who are reporting the functional change, the mechanism of injury. When somebody sees a mechanism of injury, if it's a severe impact, if it's a hard fall caught on surveillance and you see somebody's head bouncing on a concrete floor, the easier case is when somebody looks at that, their common sense is, that could have injured the brain. The harder case is that happens every day. People aren't walking around with TBIs. So everything's on this scale and you've got the mechanism of injury, you got the reported consequence afterwards. Was it loss of consciousness or was it a little confused? Were they out? Did they have short-term memory loss? Was that reported immediately? So you got all these factors that lead up to how strong your case is from the mechanism of injury, the status of the plaintiff right afterwards, the strength of that evidence as far as loss of consciousness or disorientation, is that credible evidence to show that?

(17:34):

And then the functional loss, how credible are the family members and the friends and all that stuff? And then how strong is your medical evidence if you work it up and have these tests done? And then like we said earlier, is there anything else going on with the plaintiff that can explain this other than this impact? So you build up all those things and all of them matter to the jury. Like I said, this is not a broken femur or a broken back that you put up on a screen in front of a jury and say, "Look." They're having to assess whether they believe that these life-changing consequences are caused by this incident and you have to build that thing up across the board. Now, I would tell you that if you prove it and if they believe you in fact had a traumatic brain injury and this changed your personality and you're a new person and your children and your grandchildren and your spouse no longer has the person they had before, they can put huge evaluations on it, huge value, because it is a very, very serious injury.

(18:32):

You don't have but one brain in this life. And if your brain has been damaged and the doctors start talking about the disease process and this is what you don't live with and this can be worse and this can be making you more susceptible to dementia or more susceptible to brain problems in the future, and they can be very large cases, but they're like everything else, you got to prove them up. And TBIs, you have to cross the T's and dot the I's and hire experts and prove up the case. There can be other people to say, "I'm not the same," and they don't have a mechanism of injury or they don't have any kind of altered mental status. And those two things alone, even with people reporting functional problems, you can have experts look at it and they say, "Ah, the mechanism of injury's not there," or, "This is not there, and they have these preexisting problems. I can't opine that that was caused by this incident." So it's across the board, but if you can prove it up with credible evidence, it can be large cases.

Pearl Carey (19:25):

Absolutely. So medical testimony, physical evidence, all of those things are of the utmost importance to get a South Carolina juror to see your point of view as somebody who suffers with a TBI.

Dirk Derrick (19:36):

That's right. We have a checklist. He goes everything we look at in a TBI. Let's look and see if it exists. Let's look and see if the proof is there. What I tell our attorneys here, I want to know everything in the world about these things. And then once we learn everything in the world about it, let's appraise it in front of the community and see what they think. And then let's leverage what they think to get our client pay the real value of their claim.

Pearl Carey (19:58):

Absolutely. Well, thank you so much, Dirk, for meeting with me today to discuss the truth about traumatic brain injuries and personal injury cases. And thank you to our listeners for joining us for yet another episode. I'm Pearl Carey, and this is Dirk Derrick.

Dirk Derrick (20:17):

Thank you.

Voiceover (20:17):

Thank you for joining us on The Legal Truth podcast. If you have questions that you would like answered on a future episode, please send them to thelegaltruth@derricklawfirm.com. If you would like to speak to us directly, call us at 843-248-7486. If you find the podcast valuable, please leave us a five-star review and share The Legal Truth with your neighbor, friend, or family member who is seeking reliable information about a South Carolina personal injury or workers' compensation claim. Dirk J. Derrick of Derrick Law Firm Injury Lawyers is responsible for the production of this podcast located at 901 North Main Street, Conway, South Carolina. Derrick Law Firm Injury Lawyers has included the information on this podcast as a service to the general public. Use of this podcast and any related materials does not in any manner constitute an attorney-client relationship between Derrick Law Firm Injury Lawyers and the user.

(21:09):

While the information on this podcast is about legal issues, it is not intended as legal advice and should not be used as a substitute for competent legal advice from a licensed professional attorney in your particular state. Anyone seeking specific legal advice or assistance should retain an attorney. Any prior results mentioned do not guarantee a similar outcome. The content reflects the personal views and opinions of the participants in the podcast and are not intended as endorsements of any views or products. This podcast could contain inaccuracies. The information contained in this podcast does not constitute legal advice and is not guaranteed to be correct, complete, or up to date as laws continue to change. In this podcast, you'll hear information about focus groups. Please note that not all of the firm's cases are presented to a focus group. Additionally, when speaking about juries or jurors in relation to a focus group, we are speaking of focus group participants and not actual trial juries or jurors.